Programming vs. GIS software for Cartography

Programming vs. GIS software for Cartography#

Cartography requires precise tools for efficient and effective map-making. New learners often face the decision between the programming approach (for example with Python) or using specialized GIS software (such as QGIS). By the end of this course, you will have a better idea of the strengths and limitations of each of these approaches. However, to get you started, this short guide aims to provide a brief comparison of both approaches, highlighting the pros and cons of each.

Python for Cartography#

Python is a versatile programming language that has become a staple in the field of geographic information systems (GIS) due to its capability to handle complex data processing and automation.

Pros:#

  • Flexibility and Scalability: Python excels in handling varying scales of data, allowing for custom scripts that can adapt to the complexities of different geographic datasets.

  • Integration: Its ability to integrate with various technologies and data formats makes Python ideal for projects requiring extensive data manipulation and automated workflows.

  • Rich Libraries: Python is supported by libraries like Geopandas, Matplotlib, and Shapely, which facilitate a wide range of geographic computations and visualizations. Additionally, there are powerful libraries for image processing and editing that provide further possibilities to enhance our maps.

  • Automation: The possibility to automate and optimize processes is a key motivation for the use of programming approaches in GIS in general, and cartography is no exception. If there is a need to make repeated maps (for the same area or different), or to visualize real-time data, then the programming approach is your best friend.

Cons:#

  • Steep Learning Curve: The requirement to understand programming concepts can pose a challenge for beginners.

  • Less Visual: Python’s script-based environments generally lack the interactive, visual interfaces that many GIS software options provide.

  • More DIY needed: Software packages come with ready tools to make many of the common visualization types in an interactive way. Although there are many Python libraries making many tasks easy, for certain visualizations you need to use your own creativity.

GIS Software#

GIS software, such as QGIS, often offers user-friendly graphical interfaces and is specifically designed for spatial data handling and map creation.

Pros:#

  • User-Friendly Interface: GIS software often comes with an intuitive graphical user interface that makes it easier for beginners and professionals alike to create and manipulate maps.

  • Rich Plugin Ecosystem: Many GIS programs have a robust selection of plugins, extending their functionality without the need for complex programming. This is particularly relevant for QGIS.

  • Community Support: There is typically strong community support with extensive documentation and forums, which are invaluable for troubleshooting and learning.

Cons:#

  • Limited Customization: While highly versatile, GIS software may not offer the same level of customization as for example a custom Python script.

  • Performance Issues: Some GIS applications may struggle with very large datasets or complex analyses compared to optimized Python scripts.

Combining Python and GIS Software#

In practice, a cartographer needs a suite of tools in their inventory to make good maps. Often, utilizing both Python and GIS software combines the strengths of each, enhancing the cartographic process by integrating technical robustness with user-centric design. Pros of the combined use of these approaches:

  • Comprehensive Capabilities: Python’s scripting abilities can automate data analyses and complex geoprocessing tasks, while GIS software can effectively visualize and manipulate spatial data.

  • Efficiency: Integrating Python within GIS software, like using Python scripts through GIS software’s console or API (e.g., PyQGIS or ArcPy), can automate tasks and improve workflows.

  • Best of Both Worlds: A combined approach harnesses the flexibility of Python with the powerful visualization tools of GIS software, making it often a good choice for both simple and complex cartographic projects.

Conclusion#

Python and GIS software each offer unique benefits to the field of cartography. Python provides powerful data manipulation and customization, while GIS software excels in intuitive mapping and spatial data manipulation. Depending on your specific needs and skills, either of these approaches or a combination of both can be used to produce high-quality maps and visualizations.

[ ]:
Contents